Please wait ...
0% Complete
Home
/
15th International Conference on Computer and Knowledge Engineering
Human vs NotebookLM for Educational Podcasts: A Controlled Experiment on Two General Topics
Authors :
Ali Banihashemi
1
Amirali Shahriary
2
Yadollah Yaghoobzadeh
3
1- ECE department, University of Tehran
2- ECE department, University of Tehran
3- ECE department, University of Tehran
Keywords :
Educational Podcasts،Google NotebookLM،Human-AI Comparison،Large Language Models (LLMs)،AI-Generated Content
Abstract :
Abstract—Podcasting has become a prominent medium in education, valued for its flexibility, accessibility, and potential to enhance student learning. However, creating high-quality educational podcasts is labor-intensive, limiting widespread adoption. Recent advancements in generative artificial intelligence offer new opportunities for automating podcast creation using large language models (LLMs). This study investigates the effectiveness of LLM-generated podcasts compared to traditional human-generated podcasts, focusing on comprehension and engagement among non-native English speakers. Our primary goal is to evaluate whether LLM-based tools—specifically Google's NotebookLM—can produce educational podcasts that match or surpass the learning value of human-created content. We conduct a controlled experiment using two general topics and human and LLM-generated podcasts to assess comprehension outcomes and subjective listener experiences. Results reveal that LLM-generated podcasts consistently lead to higher comprehension scores and are rated more topically focused than human-generated podcasts, with positive but not always significant trends in clarity and engagement. These findings suggest that LLM-generated podcasts can serve as a scalable and effective alternative to human-generated podcasts, offering new possibilities for personalized, accessible learning in digital education environments.
Papers List
List of archived papers
Intelligent Rule Extraction in Complex Event Processing Platform for Health Monitoring Systems
Mohammad Mehdi Naseri - Shima Tabibian - Elaheh Homayounvala
Bipartite link prediction improvement using the effective utilization of edge betweenness centrality
Sadegh Sulaimany Sulaimany - Yasin Amini
Characterizing Microsatellite Distribution Patterns Across Distinct Gene Categories in Human
Elahe Mehrazin - Mahmoud Naghibzadeh - Sara Jamali
Generating Hand-Written Symbols With Trajectory Planning Using A Robotic Arm
Arya Parvizi - Armin Salimi-Badr
A Weighted TF-IDF-based Approach for Authorship Attribution
Ali Abedzadeh - Reza Ramezani - Afsaneh Fatemi
Improving Machine Learning Classification of Heart Disease Using the Graph-Based Techniques
Abolfazl Dibaji - Sadegh Sulaimany
Intelligent Resource Collision Management for Cellular Vehicular Systems Using Software-Defined Networking
Mohammad Kazemiesfeh - Neda Moghim - Ahmadreza Montazerolghaem
Averting Mode Collapse for Generative Zero-Shot Learning
Shayan Ramazi - Setare Shabani
AIRSPAN-X: Federated XGBoost with Sequential Anomaly Detection for Explainable Urban Air Quality Prediction
Saghar Shafaati - S. Hossein Erfani
A Novel Method For Fake News Detection Based on Propagation Tree
Mansour Davoudi - Mohammad Reza Moosavi - Mohammad Hadi Sadreddini
more
Samin Hamayesh - Version 46.0.2